By Nichola Groom
Nov 18 (Reuters) – The future of wind farms, data centers, oil pipelines and transmission lines could hinge on whether the US Congress approves a permitting overhaul that backers say would cut electricity costs, but critics warn would weaken environmental protections.
The 400-page Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, expected to receive a final vote in the Senate this week, would accelerate approvals for major energy and infrastructure projects by cutting timelines for environmental reviews and litigation.
WHAT PROBLEM IS THE BILL TRYING TO SOLVE?
Democrats and Republicans alike have argued for decades that the US takes too long to build large infrastructure projects.
The issue has taken on urgency as AI’s rapid growth drives electricity demand, raising concerns about power prices, transmission bottlenecks and whether the grid can expand quickly to support new data centers.
SunZia, a 550-mile (885-km) transmission line to deliver wind power from New Mexico to Arizona and California, for example, took nearly two decades to move from proposal to completion.
WHAT WOULD THE BILL DO?
• Speed environmental reviews. The bill would impose deadlines on many federal reviews, require agencies to coordinate permitting decisions and create a federal permitting tracker. The bill would set a two-year target for major federal environmental reviews, compared with an average of more than four years now, according to the White House Council of Economic Advisers.
• Make data centers pay. One of the bill’s most closely watched provisions would require large data centers to bear more of the transmission and infrastructure costs associated with their electricity demand.
• Expand transmission development. The legislation includes provisions intended to accelerate planning, siting and construction of transmission lines and upgrades to existing infrastructure.
• Increase permit certainty. The bill would limit circumstances under which permits can be revoked or challenged in court. It establishes a 150-day window for many legal challenges after permits or reviews, replacing a patchwork of deadlines that can allow litigation to emerge months, even years, after approvals.
• Supporters say permit certainty would give investors confidence to move forward. Critics argue it limits accountability and judicial review.
WHAT ABOUT TRUMP’S FREEZE ON WIND PROJECTS?
The provisions meant to prevent challenges and delays were included to prevent political swings resulting in project cancellations. Former Democratic President Joe Biden, for example, canceled the Keystone XL oil pipeline permit while President Donald Trump’s Republican administration has frozen and delayed wind projects.
Some Democratic lawmakers and environmental groups say they need further assurances that Trump would follow the law, after he said this month: “I will not approve wind turbines because wind turbines are a major loser.”
WHY HAS THE BILL BECOME TIED TO DATA CENTERS?
In response to widespread opposition to data center development from communities nationwide, the bill would require large computing facilities to bear more of the costs they impose on the grid.
Critics argue that loosening permitting requirements for all industries will only make data centers easier to build.
HOW WOULD THE BILL LOWER ENERGY PRICES?
Supporters argue delays in permitting power plants, transmission lines and other infrastructure raise costs for consumers and businesses. The White House Council of Economic Advisers estimated the bill could increase annual economic output by $82 billion to $164 billion and reduce average household electric bills by roughly $178 to $251 per year.
Independent analyses generally conclude the bill would lower costs. Resources for the Future estimated it would significantly expand transmission capacity and generate $350 billion in savings through 2050, while Rhodium Group found it could lower climate-warming emissions.
WHY ARE ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS AND TRIBES OPPOSED?
Environmental groups including the League of Conservation Voters, Sierra Club and Natural Resources Defense Council support the bill’s transmission and clean-energy provisions but argue it would also accelerate fossil-fuel development and weaken protections for public lands, water, wildlife and communities.
Tribal organizations, including the National Congress of American Indians, say the bill prioritizes faster approvals over protections for sacred sites and tribal consultation.
WHY ARE DEMOCRATS DIVIDED?
The biggest Democratic disagreement is about whether to pass the bipartisan bill now or pursue a stronger version next year, when the party takes control of the House of Representatives and Senate.
Democratic Senators Martin Heinrich of New Mexico and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island, who authored the bill with Republicans Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia and Mike Lee of Utah, say voters want lower energy costs now and that Congress can strengthen environmental protections later.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?
The Senate has voted overwhelmingly to clear two procedural hurdles.
The bill still faces a final Senate vote, expected this week, and consideration by the House. Passage in the House this year remains uncertain due to the divide among Democrats and as Congress works to fund the government before federal funding expires on December 11.
(Reporting by Nichola Groom; Editing by Rod Nickel)
Brought to you by www.srnnews.com
No coordination or foreign state behind recent US outages, Clayton says
US single-family housing starts rebound in October; building permits plunge
US senators warn White House that AI-enabled cyber threats are outpacing defenses